In a June 6, 2025 decision by Justice Linda S. Jamieson in Moshe Bain v. Samuel Strulovitch, et al., the Westchester County Commercial Division denied two motions to dismiss in a complex dispute concerning ownership interests in a Mount Vernon nursing home and the real estate on which it operates. The litigation centers on
In Bardy v. Bonnem, Index No. 55909/2023, Justice Linda S. Jamieson of the Westchester County Commercial Division issued a detailed decision addressing contract formation, fiduciary duties, and quasi-contract claims in the context of a failed business venture.
Background
The case arose out of an alleged oral agreement between plaintiff Jack Bardy, an experienced hospitality
On May 20, 2025, the Chief Administrative Judge of the Courts signed Administrative Order 111/25, introducing significant developments for litigators practicing in the Commercial Division. Effective July 7, 2025, the Order adds a new Appendix E – a Model Pre-Trial Order – to Section 202.70 of the Uniform Rules of the Supreme and County Courts
In Gregory F. Holcombe v. James L. Moskovitz and JOY-CPW, Inc., Index No. 67400/2024, Justice Linda S. Jamieson of the Westchester Commercial Division denied a motion to appoint a receiver over the judgment debtor’s business assets. The court found the request premature, as the plaintiff had not yet exhausted other available enforcement tools.
Background
Starting July 7, 2025, a new Rule 23 will take effect in the Commercial Division of the New York Supreme Court, authorizing the filing of amicus curiae briefs for the first time in trial-level proceedings. This important development further cements the Commercial Division’s role—both statewide and here in Westchester—as a forward-thinking venue for resolving sophisticated
Westchester Commercial Division Justice Linda S. Jamieson issued a detailed Decision and Order in Camsan Inc. v. OPRA III LLC, Index No. 64814/2022 (and related actions), addressing multiple motions involving mechanic’s liens filed against a large residential construction project in Rye. The decision clarifies the application of New York’s Lien Law in the context
In Pantelis P. Mestousis et al. v. Michael Saccente, Justice Gretchen Walsh of the Westchester Commercial Division denied dueling motions for summary judgment in a sprawling dispute over a failed multimillion-dollar quarry acquisition and an alleged $70,000 personal loan. The decision highlights the court’s rigorous application of summary judgment standards, particularly in the context
In Michael Cushner, M.D. v. Summit Health Management LLC, Index No. 65930/2024, Justice Gretchen Walsh of the Westchester Commercial Division issued a detailed Decision and Order addressing a motion to dismiss by defendants Summit Health, VillageMD, and City Medical. Dr. Cushner—a former orthopedic surgeon at WestMed—claims he is owed millions under his employment and
In a recent decision by Westchester Commercial Division Justice Linda S. Jamieson, the Court declined to permit a late-stage amendment to the complaint that sought to introduce new claims against an additional corporate defendant. The case serves as a noteworthy example of the court’s careful application of procedural principles and substantive corporate law doctrines—particularly regarding
In a recent decision in Beck Chevrolet Co., Inc. v. Brian Levine, Justice Linda S. Jamieson of the Westchester Commercial Division denied a motion for preliminary injunction brought by a Westchester-based car dealership against its former Sales Manager. The decision is a cautionary tale for employers asserting trade secret claims and seeking injunctive relief
